The Argentina international questioned the club’s recruitment strategy and the level of investment made in strengthening the squad during the summer transfer window. He specifically expressed disappointment with director of football Jason Wilcox, arguing that responsibility for the team’s struggles should not fall solely on the manager and players.

Martínez made the comments after United’s defeat in Madrid on Tuesday, October 13, 2026. His remarks drew attention to concerns about the club’s squad depth and its ability to compete against leading European teams.

According to football transfer journalist Fabrizio Romano, the club subsequently imposed a fine and considers the matter resolved. However, Manchester United have not publicly confirmed the reported punishment or disclosed any amount involved.

The defender held talks with head coach Michael Carrick and senior club officials at the club’s training ground on Thursday, October 15, in an effort to resolve the disagreement.

Following the meeting, Martínez issued a public apology, acknowledging that his frustration after the defeat had influenced the timing and manner of his comments.

He explained that the discussions with the club’s leadership had been positive and allowed those involved to exchange views openly.

Martínez also stressed the importance of unity at Manchester United, recognising that his remarks had not helped the club’s collective objectives. He said the team was now focused on moving forward and working towards success.

The controversy followed United’s disappointing performance against Atlético Madrid, which intensified scrutiny of the club’s early-season form and recruitment decisions.

Although Martínez directed much of his criticism towards the club’s leadership, he did not absolve the players of responsibility. He maintained that the team also needed to improve while arguing that stronger squad investment was necessary to compete consistently at the highest level.

The reported fine appears to have brought the immediate disciplinary dispute to a close, although the club has not released an official statement confirming the sanction.

Martínez’s contract runs until June 2027, with Manchester United holding an option to extend it for another year. His longer-term future at Old Trafford remains a separate question from the disciplinary issue.

For now, the defender’s apology and reported discussions with the club’s leadership have helped bring the public disagreement to a close, with attention returning to Manchester United’s performances on the pitch.

Reporting by TalkNaijaMedia