The appeals, registered as CA/ABJ/CV/1114/2026 and CA/ABJ/CV/1105/2026, arose from a judgment delivered by the Federal Capital Territory High Court in Abuja on May 5, 2026.
In that ruling, Justice Yusuf Halilu awarded N100 million in damages to two DSS officers, Sarah John and Gabriel Ogundele, over publications made by SERAP concerning an alleged visit by security operatives to the organisation’s Abuja office in September 2024.
The lower court also directed SERAP and Oluwadare to issue public apologies through specified national newspapers, television stations and the organisation’s online platforms. It further awarded N1 million in litigation costs and imposed 10 per cent annual interest on the judgment sum until payment.
SERAP and Oluwadare are asking the appellate court to overturn the decision, arguing that the trial court made errors in its assessment of the evidence and the legal principles governing defamation.
One of their central arguments is that the two DSS officers were not identified by name, rank, official designation or photograph in the publications. They contend that the physical descriptions relied upon by the claimants were too general to establish that the statements referred specifically to them.
The appellants also challenged the trial judge’s reliance on his personal observation of the officers in court to establish that they matched the descriptions in the publications. They maintained that identification should have been established through evidence showing that readers could connect the descriptions to the claimants when the publications were made.
They further questioned the evidence presented to support claims of professional and psychological harm, arguing that the alleged damage to the officers’ reputations was not sufficiently established through independent evidence.
SERAP and Oluwadare maintained that their publications addressed the conduct of security officials and matters of public interest. They also argued that the trial court did not properly consider their defences, including justification, qualified privilege and the constitutional protection of freedom of expression.
The respondents, however, opposed the appeals and urged the Court of Appeal to uphold the lower court's decision. Their position is that the publications and the circumstances surrounding the incident were sufficient to identify them, despite the absence of their names.
During Monday’s proceedings, counsel for the appellants urged the court to allow the appeals and set aside the judgment, while the respondents’ legal team called for their dismissal.
With judgment now reserved, the Court of Appeal is expected to determine whether the lower court was right to hold SERAP and its deputy director liable for defamation and impose the financial and apology orders.
Reporting by TalkNaijaMedia
Reader Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first to share your perspective on this report.