The notice of appeal, filed by the commission’s lawyer, E.E. Iheanacho, SAN, challenges the trial court’s handling of the evidence presented during the forfeiture proceedings.
In its grounds of appeal, the EFCC argued that the judge failed to properly evaluate evidence concerning Yisawu’s earnings while serving with the Nigerian National Petroleum Corporation (NNPC) and the funds he allegedly paid to two Bureau de Change operators, Samaila Bala and Rasheed Yusuf.
The commission claimed that between September 2020 and September 2023, the former refinery chief’s income was substantially below the $912,550 he allegedly paid to the two foreign-exchange dealers.
It also disputed the court’s assessment of the source of funds used to develop the disputed properties and acquire treasury bills. According to the EFCC, Yisawu did not provide a satisfactory explanation establishing that the money came from legitimate sources.
The commission further referred to evidence it identified as Exhibit EFCC 18, arguing that Yisawu used gratuity payments totalling ₦368,894,865.28 to acquire other properties and Federal Government of Nigeria Savings Bonds between November 2023 and December 2024. It maintained that the funds allegedly paid to the Bureau de Change operators were separate from his pension and gratuity.
Another major issue raised in the appeal concerns Yisawu’s asset declaration. The EFCC argued that the trial judge was wrong to conclude that he had declared his assets, claiming that the Code of Conduct Bureau (CCB) allegedly informed the commission that it had no record of the relevant declaration.
The commission’s lawyer also argued that the court did not sufficiently consider the EFCC’s powers to request and obtain official records from government institutions, including the CCB.
The EFCC is asking the appellate court to set aside Justice Omotosho’s decision and grant the final forfeiture of the funds and properties it considers reasonably suspected to be proceeds of unlawful activities.
The appeal follows the Federal High Court’s November 9 ruling, which set aside the interim forfeiture order and rejected the commission’s application for permanent forfeiture.
In reaching his decision, Justice Omotosho considered financial records and explanations presented by both parties. The judge held that the EFCC had not established that Yisawu’s wealth was disproportionate to his legitimate earnings from 32 years of service in the oil and gas industry.
The court also accepted evidence that the two Lagos properties targeted by the commission were acquired between 2015 and 2020, before Yisawu became managing director of the Warri refinery in November 2022. His tenure in that position ended in September 2023.
Yisawu, through his lawyer, Wale Balogun, SAN, maintained that his salaries, allowances, estacodes and other earnings accumulated over his long career provided the resources used to acquire the properties and investments.
He also argued that he had obtained foreign currency through lawful transactions in the open market and denied wrongdoing in connection with the refinery project.
The former managing director further maintained that neither the NNPC, its successor company, the Warri refinery nor the contractor involved in the project had lodged a complaint against him over his conduct or handling of the contract.
Justice Omotosho ultimately found that the evidence presented by Yisawu outweighed the commission’s submissions, describing the EFCC’s evidence as insufficient to justify the forfeiture.
However, the forfeiture proceedings are separate from the criminal case involving Yisawu. The EFCC had earlier filed an eight-count money laundering charge against him involving an alleged ₦1.339 billion. He pleaded not guilty when arraigned in July 2026.
The criminal case is before Justice Inyang Ekwo, who fixed January 18, 19 and 20, 2027, for the commencement of trial. The allegations in that case have not been established by a court.
The latest appeal means the dispute over the ownership and alleged source of the assets will continue before the courts. The Federal High Court’s decision remains the ruling under challenge, while the EFCC’s claims in its notice of appeal are arguments yet to be determined by the appellate court.
Reporting by TalkNaijaMedia
Reader Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first to share your perspective on this report.